Home  Contact Us
  Follow Us On:
 
Search:
Advertising Advertising Free Newsletter Free E-Newsletter
NEWS

Man sues over bloody steak after he ordered medium rare
Published on: 2022-08-02
Share to
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 

A man in Shanghai has filed a lawsuit against a restaurant seeking compensation of 21,000 yuan after being served a bloody medium rare steak.

The man, surnamed Wu, dined at a local Western-style restaurant in the city and ordered a steak. When the waiter suggested he have it medium well done, Wu insisted on a medium rare steak which will usually have some blood inside. However, Wu was angry when he was served a bloody steak.

Wu asked for a free meal, but the restaurant refused. He then paid the bill of 2,110 yuan and then took the steak home.

Wu is arguing in his claim that the restaurant has violated the Food Safety Law. He is seeking compensation many times more than what he paid for the steak.

The court rejected Wu’s case because the restaurant had used proper cooking techniques when preparing the meal.

点了五分熟牛排,却因看到血丝索赔2万!

据上海铁路运输法院,2022年1月,吴某与朋友在某餐饮公司所属的餐厅用餐,吴某点了若干餐品,合计花费2110元,其中包含一份单价1688元的“澳洲M6+T骨牛排”,点餐时吴某要求五分熟。

餐厅工作人员询问吴某,是否按中国人习惯食用七分熟牛排,但吴某仍坚持要五分熟牛排。

菜品上齐后,吴某在食用牛排的过程中,认为牛排带有血丝生肉,要求餐厅免单,但遭拒。吴某遂支付了餐费并将剩余牛排打包后与朋友离开。

事后,吴某向上铁法院起诉,认为涉案牛排有部分为完全生肉,不满足可食用标准,违反了食品安全法,请求法院判决该餐饮公司支付价款十倍的惩罚金21,100元。

对于吴某的诉讼请求,法院认为,西餐牛排熟度是烹饪制作工艺问题,本案中,吴某认为餐厅按照自己五分熟牛排需求提供的带有血丝生肉牛排不符合食品安全标准,显然是将牛排的烹饪制作工艺与食品安全标准混为一谈。吴某也并未明确指出涉案牛排不符合哪项食品安全标准,也未举证说明餐厅的餐饮服务存在不符合食品安全标准的具体事实。

故吴某要求被告支付价款十倍的惩罚金的诉请缺乏事实与法律依据,法院不予支持,遂判决驳回吴某的诉讼请求。

Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
    Subscription    |     Advertising    |     Contact Us    |
Address: Magnetic Plaza, Building A4, 6th Floor, Binshui Xi Dao.
Nankai District. 300381 TIANJIN. PR CHINA
Tel: +86 22 23917700
E-mail: webmaster@businesstianjin.com
Copyright 2024 BusinessTianjin.com. All rights reserved.